|  
             The Ideal Muslim Husband 
              
            Much 
              ink has been spilled, and much breath, in defining the role of Muslim 
              women; the rights of Muslim women; the duties of Muslim women, what 
              constitutes an ideal Muslim wife. Maybe because there has so much 
              misunderstanding of the role of women, we seem to give it special 
              emphasis in lectures and books. However since men and women are 
              interdependent, it is not wise to concentrate on one and remain 
              silent about the other. 
            The 
              last time I was invited to speak about "The ideal Muslim Wife", 
              I made a promise that my next assignment would be to prepare a lecture 
              on " The ideal Muslim Husband". Many men seem to feel that women, 
              and their wives in particular, should be ideal Muslims, while they 
              themselves and their fellow men behave as they like without reference 
              to the Qur’an and Sunnah, and unchallenged by the Shari’ah. 
            This 
              paper is therefore intended to redress the balance; to turn the 
              spotlight on to the men, so that they might be aware of the Islamic 
              standard for an ideal husband, as they try to reach that standard 
              as much as they wish their wives to reach the standard of an ideal 
              Muslim wife. 
            The 
              obvious place to look for these standards of behaviour is in the 
              Qur’an and Hadith. 
            Let 
              us therefore start at the beginning. How does the ideal husband 
              behave before marriage? After all, a man does not totally change 
              his character with effect from his wedding day. The bride is joining 
              her life with that of another person whose personality and habits 
              have been in some degree already formed. What then should be the 
              behavior towards women by a young man before marriage? 
            Islam 
              does not accept the view common in the western secular society that 
              before marriage a young man is expected to "sow his wild oats" - 
              whether by frequenting prostitutes or by sleeping around, or having 
              any form of "trial marriage". For all such activities the Qur’an 
              has prescribed a legal punishment of 100 lashes. [Qur’an 24:2] 
            The 
              Qur’an moreover says; 
            "And 
              as for those who are unable to marry,  
              let them live in continence until Allah grants them sufficiently 
              out of his bounty...."  
              [Qur’an 
              24:33] 
            To 
              assist young men in this situation the Prophet (saws) in a Hadith 
              recorded in Bukhari further advised; 
            "Young 
              men, those of you who can support a wife should marry, for it keeps 
              you from looking at women and preserves your chastity; but those 
              who cannot should fast, for it is a means of cooling passion." 
            For 
              those who have the means to get married, how should they go about 
              it? We have mentioned that the modern western practice of having 
              girlfriends and trial marriages is emphatically unlawful for Muslims. 
              Instead it is expected that the family and friends will play a big 
              role in finding out in detail about the character and circumstances 
              of the proposed partner before allowing the feelings of the boy 
              and girl to be aroused has several advantages. Its effect is to 
              cut out a lot of the embarrassment, temptation and heartache which 
              are common in the western system of courtship and intimate relations 
              before marriage. 
            The 
              boy is expected to share with his parents certain priorities in 
              the type of girl he hopes to marry, and this is mentioned in a Hadith 
              related by Abu Hurairah in which the Prophet (saws) advised: 
            "A 
              women may be sought for her wealth, her birth, her beauty or he 
              religious character. But do look for the religious women. And if 
              you do it for any other consideration, your hands be rubbed in dirt!" 
              [Bukhari 
              and Muslim] 
            In 
              other words the key to success in marriage is seen as the moral 
              quality of the partner. The ideal Muslim bridegroom therefore goes 
              into marriage with the responsible attitude of a person establishing 
              a family on the best possible foundation of love and mutual compassion, 
              and not of infatuation over beauty, ambition for wealth or social 
              position. The Qur’an has described the marriage relationship in 
              these terms; 
            "Among 
              His signs is the fact that he has created spouses from among yourselves, 
              so that you may find tranquillity with them; and he has put love 
              and mercy between you. In that are signs for people who reflect." 
               
              [Qur’an 
              30:21] 
            and 
              again: 
            "They 
              (wives) are garments for you, while you are garments for them." 
               
              [Qur’an 
              2:187] 
            Having 
              sought his bride in an honourable way, and married her in the manner 
              prescribed by the Prophet- that is with public celebration but the 
              minimum of fuss and ostentation- what are the Muslim husband’s duties? 
            His 
              first duty is maintenance and protection, and overall responsibility 
              for the welfare of his wife, which is prescribed in the Qur’an: 
            "Men 
              shall take full care of women with the bounties which Allah has 
              bestowed more abundantly on the former than on the latter, and with 
              what they may spend out of their possessions....".  
              [Qur’an 
              4:34] 
            This 
              includes feeding, clothing and shelter for the wife and for any 
              children of the marriage. This is a legally enforceable duty, which 
              remains even after divorce until the expiry of the Iddah or even 
              longer in the view of some of the scholars. Financial responsibility 
              for the family therefore rests squarely on the husband, and the 
              wife has no duty to contribute to family expenses unless she has 
              the means and the wish to do so. 
            The 
              legal obligations of a husband do not stop with provision of the 
              basic requirements relating to maintenance and protection. He is 
              also expected to give her company and marital relations, and to 
              avoid doing anything that would harm her. 
            These 
              obligations are enforced by the Shari’ah. If a man fails to maintain 
              his wife or fails to visit her for more than a certain period of 
              time, the wife has grounds to be granted a divorce by a Shari’ah 
              Court. Similarly, if she can prove to the court that the husband 
              is doing harm (Idrar), be it by drinking alcohol, or beating her 
              without lawful cause, or abusing her or her parents and so on, she 
              is entitled to be granted a divorce. In none of these cases can 
              the husband claim back any part of the dowry or presents he has 
              given to the wife. I would like to make a note here that every situation 
              has to be evaluated on its merits and circumstances by a Shar'iah 
              Court. These points mentioned above are general precepts in the 
              Shar'iah. 
            The 
              Husband is however urged in the Qur’an to avoid divorce and try 
              to preserve marriage even if it is not ideal. This is to be done 
              in the first instance by exercising patience with his wife’s faults. 
              The Qur’an say’s; 
            "Live 
              with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If you take a dislike 
              to them, it may be that you dislike a thing while Allah brings about 
              through it a great deal of good."  
              [Qur’an 
              4:19] 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) also emphasised the undesirability of divorce in 
              a Hadith found in Abu Dau’d’s collection: 
            "The 
              most hateful of all lawful things, in the sight of Allah, is divorce." 
            The 
              ideal husband should therefore, if need arises, make full use of 
              Qur’anic provisions for reconciliation and arbitration [Qur’an 
              4:34] before proceeding with divorce 
            If 
              a man does divorce his wife, he should follow the steps approved 
              in the Qur’an and Sunnah regarding a revocable divorce. This allows 
              for cooling off and reconciliation before it becomes final on the 
              final pronouncement. The divorce is not to be pronounced while the 
              wife is in menstruation, but when she has finished menstruation 
              and not yet resumed marital relations with the husband. (Qur’an 
              65:1) In other words divorce is not to be pronounced in anger or 
              at random, but at a specific time when the husband is in control 
              of his reason, and the wife herself is not in the state of emotional 
              upset that sometimes occurs whilst she is pregnant or may accompany 
              menstruation. 
            The 
              husband is to continue good treatment of his wife even if divorce 
              decided upon. He is to keep and feed her as before in his own house 
              until the expiry of her iddah (waiting period) without harassment, 
              [Qur’an 65:1, 65:6] and to make provision for her according 
              to his means. 
            He 
              is not to take back any of the gifts he may have given her before 
              or during the marriage: 
            "The 
              parties should either hold together on equitable terms or separate 
              with kindness. It is not lawful for you (men) to take back any of 
              your gifts from your wives." 
              [Qur’an 
              2:229] 
            On 
              the contrary, the husband is to give her a gift or some form of 
              maintenance to sustain her after divorce [Qur’an 2:241]. Moreover, 
              he is not to interfere if after divorce she wishes to marry someone 
              else: 
            "......and 
              when you divorce women and they have reached the end of their waiting 
              term, hinder them not from marrying other men if they have agreed 
              with each other in a fair manner." 
              [Qur’an 
              2:232] 
            The 
              husband should also know that according to the Shari’ah he is not 
              always the one to have custody of his children after divorce, contrary 
              to the common practice in some countries. It is the wife who is 
              given priority in custody of children in many cases, in accordance 
              with a Hadith related by Amru b. Shu’aib in Ibn Majah, which tells 
              how a woman came to the Prophet (saws) and said: 
            "Truly 
              my belly served as a container for my son here, and my breast served 
              as a skin bag for him (to drink out of), and my bosom served as 
              a refuge for him; and now his father has divorced me, and he (also) 
              desires to take away from me." The Prophet (saws) said: "You have 
              a better right to have him as long as you do not marry again." [Ibn 
              Majah] 
            We 
              would also like to point out again however, that the decision as 
              to the custody of the children has to be evaluated by a Shar'iah 
              Court, which will consider the particular circumstances surrounding 
              the family and the children's best welfare. 
            In 
              the Maliki School of Islamic Jurisprudence, this rule is systematised 
              to give priority in custody of children to the mother and to 5 other 
              relatives before the custody could be claimed by the father. This 
              custody lasts until puberty for a son and until marriage for a daughter, 
              while the financial responsibility for their maintenance remains 
              with their father. 
            The 
              knowledge of the necessity of separation from his children must 
              certainly act as a reality check when a husband is indiscriminately 
              deciding to divorce. 
            It 
              should also be realised the husband is required to be faithful in 
              marriage as the wife must. The punishment for adultery of a married 
              person, male or female, under the Shari’ah is death. The fact that 
              the punishment may not be applied in this world, does not make the 
              sin any less in the sight of Allah. A sin that is not expiated in 
              this world is after all going to follow a person to the grave. 
            Therefore 
              the husband should not fail to follow Allah’s command in the Qur’an: 
            "Tell 
              the believing men to lower their gaze and to be mindful of their 
              chastity: verily this will be most conductive to their purity (and) 
              verily Allah is aware of all that they do." 
              [Qur’an 
              24:30] 
            Those 
              married men who cruise around in their cars looking for school girls 
              to pick up are surely disgracing themselves, and forfeiting all 
              right to require chastity of their wives. 
            If 
              for some reason, the husband cannot manage with his first wife but 
              does not want to divorce her, he is not prohibited from contracting 
              another marriage, provided it is done in a legal and honorable way. 
            The 
              permission to marry more then one wife at a time is however conditional: 
            ".......if 
              you fear you cannot do justice between them, then marry only one." 
              [Qur’an 
              4:3] 
            This 
              condition is often taken very lightly in some countries, where polygamy 
              has long been a social custom. No words in the Qur’an, however, 
              are without meaning, this verse should not be taken lightly. A weak 
              husband will not be respected and will not act fairly between his 
              wives, whereby, his marrying more then one is likely to lead to 
              injustice, constant disharmony and the break up of his family. This 
              is not in his interests or theirs or in the interests of the Muslim 
              Ummah. 
            If 
              having married more then one, however, a husband finds his heart 
              inclining to one at the expense of the other, he is warned that 
              this inclination should not reach the stage of neglect of the needs 
              of the other wife: 
            "And 
              you will not be able to treat your wives with equal justice however 
              much you desire it.  
              But do not incline towards one to the exclusion of the other, leaving 
              her as it were in suspense."  
              [Qur’an 
              4:29] 
            This 
              warning against injustice is strongly reinforced by the Hadith in 
              which Abu Hurairah (raa) reported the Prophet (saws) as saying: 
            "Whoever 
              has two wives and does not treat them equally, shall come on the 
              day of resurrection with half his body hanging down." [Abu 
              Da’ud, Nasa’i, and Ibn Majah] 
            We 
              have so far examined the legal framework of marriage and divorce 
              as outlined mainly in the Qur’an. This now needs to be filled in 
              with illustration and elaboration drawn from the Sunnah, since the 
              Qur’an tells us : 
            "You 
              have in the apostle of Allah a beautiful pattern of conduct for 
              anyone whose hope is in Allah and the last day." 
              [Qur’an 
              33:21] 
            How 
              did the Prophet (saws) then, behave as a husband? Obviously he observed 
              the legal framework, but how did he behave in his day-to-day relationships 
              with his wives? 
            A lot 
              of information is to be gathered about this from the Hadith, both 
              directly and indirectly, and also from the Sirah (the biography 
              of the Prophet (saws)). 
            His 
              guiding principle on the treatment of wives is stated in some well 
              known Ahadith; 
            "From 
              among the believers are those who have the kindest disposition and 
              are the kindest to their families- such are those who show the most 
              perfect faith. "The best among them are those who are kindest to 
              their wives." [Bukhari 
              and Muslim] 
            How 
              did the Prophet (saws) himself exemplify this kindness? 
            Firstly 
              he was not a difficult or remote or tyrannical husband of the 
              type who regards all household chores as "women’s work". In a Hadith 
              in Bukhari: 
            Aisha 
              (raa) was asked by Al-Aswad b. Yazid what the Prophet used to do 
              in the house. She replied: "He used to work for his family, that 
              is serve his family, and when prayer time came, he went out for 
              prayer." [Bukhari] 
            Other 
              Hadith tell us that he used to mend his own clothes. 
            Secondly 
              he didn’t make a fuss about food. It is recorded in a Hadith from 
              Abu Hurairah (raa) in the collection of Muslim: 
            "Allah’s 
              Messenger never found fault with food. If he liked something, he 
              ate it, and if he disliked it, he just abstained from it." [Muslim] 
            Implying 
              that he never complained about the food or it’s cooking. 
            Aisha 
              (raa) reported that whenever she was sick, the Prophet (saws) would 
              come to her to show his sympathy. Nor, was he ashamed to let it 
              be known that his love for his wife was greater then his love for 
              any other human being. It is recorded in the Hadith collections 
              of Bukhari and Muslim that someone asked the Prophet: "Who among 
              all the people is most beloved by you?" And he said "Aisha". 
            This 
              love and understanding for Aisha did not eclipse his high regard 
              for his first wife Khadijah, who had been his only wife for about 
              25 years until her death. Aisha (raa) reported that he always treasured 
              the memory of Khadijah who had supported and encouraged him through 
              the difficult years in Mecca, and that he use to regularly give 
              gifts to Khadijah’s closest friends as an expression of his undiminished 
              esteem and love for her. 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) never held himself apart from his wives as if they 
              were by their nature as women inferior. On the Contrary, he included 
              "playing games with one’s wife" as one of the legitimate entertainment's. 
              According to the following Hadith: 
            ".......There 
              is no amusement which is praiseworthy except three, namely training 
              a horse, sporting with one’s wife and shooting arrows with a bow." 
              [Abu 
              Da’ud, Ibn Majah and Baihaqi] 
            In 
              illustration of this practice, Aisha (raa) records that on more 
              then one occasion she and the Prophet (saws) ran races and sometimes 
              she won and sometimes he won. Most men nowadays consider it far 
              beneath their dignity to play any sort of game with their wives, 
              and their marriages are the duller and poorer for it. 
            I think 
              this is one of the problems we encounter in the way we learn about 
              the life of the Prophet (saws). Most of the history books dwell 
              on the political and military aspects of the Prophet’s (saws) life, 
              and his personality, which was obviously very attractive, eludes 
              our knowledge. We tend to, for this reason picture him as always 
              serious, while the Hadith informs us that although he rarely laughed 
              aloud, "Nobody used to smile as much as he did." This is fully in 
              accordance with the Hadith: "Smiling at your brother (Muslim) is 
              a charity." 
            The 
              Prophet’s (saws) attitude towards female children and female education 
              is a beautiful elaboration of what is found in the Qur’an. The Qur’an 
              not only forbade the jahiliyyah practice of female infanticide, 
              but even condemned the practice of showing disappointment or anger 
              over the birth of a female child. [Qur’an 16:58-59] 
            A Hadith 
              related by Ibn Abbas in fact encourages the reverse: 
            "Whoever 
              has a female child and does not bury her alive, nor hide her in 
              contempt, nor prefers his male child over her, Allah will make him 
              enter Paradise." [Abu 
              Da’ud] 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) showed the greatest love and affection for his female 
              children, particularly for Fatima. Aisha (raa) related that: 
            "Whenever 
              the Prophet (saws) saw Fatima (raa), he would welcome her, and rising 
              from his seat would kiss her, and then taking her by the hand would 
              seat her in his own seat." [Bukhari] 
            He 
              decreed that every Muslim - male and female- must as a duty seek 
              knowledge and prescribed education for all children in the following 
              words: 
            "No 
              present or gift of a parent, out of all the gifts and presents to 
              a child, is superior to a good broad (general) education." [Tirmidhi 
              and Baihaqi] 
            He 
              laid special emphasis on the education of daughters: 
            "Whoever 
              brings up two sisters or two daughters, and gives them a broad education, 
              and treats them well, and gives them in marriage, for him is Paradise." 
              [Abu 
              Da’ud, Tirmidhi] 
            This 
              concern for the education of girls was reflected in his teaching 
              of Aisha (raa), who was still a young girl when he married her, 
              and was only 18 when he died. She had a natural ability for learning 
              and a strong sense of reasoning, and he taught her as much as she 
              was ready to learn. He was so impressed and pleased with her learning 
              that he even told people: 
            "You 
              can learn half your religion from this rosy-cheeked girl." 
            He 
              therefore encouraged people to consult her in religious matters, 
              and after his death she became one of the major sources of Hadith. 
            From 
              all this we can see that some people’s resistance to allowing their 
              daughters to have access to knowledge is not only misguided but 
              quite contrary to all the Prophet (saws) preached and practiced. 
              An ideal-Muslim husband is therefore expected to be deeply committed 
              to and involved in the education of all his children - the daughters 
              as much as the son’s. 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) respect for a wife’s intelligence and understanding 
              was also reflected in his readiness to consult his wives and respond 
              to their good advice. An instance of this practice is recorded on 
              the occasion of the signing of the treaty of Hudaibihiyah. Many 
              of the Muslims were reluctant to accept treaty. They did not want 
              to go home without performing pilgrimage and they considered some 
              parts of the Treaty disadvantageous to the Muslims. They were therefore 
              reluctant to obey his instructions to slaughter their sacrificial 
              camels and shave their heads, which would symbolise that the Pilgrimage 
              was over and the matter closed. The Prophet (saws) withdrew to his 
              tent in perplexity, and told his wife Umm Salamah what had happened. 
              She advised him: "Go out and speak to no man until you have performed 
              your sacrifice." The Prophet (saws) followed her advice, and slaughtered 
              the camel calling: "Bismillah, Allahu akbar" in a loud voice, whereupon 
              the Muslims forgot their reluctance and raced to make their own 
              sacrifices. 
            The 
              presence of Umm Salamah on this journey exemplifies another aspect 
              of the Prophet’s (saws) dealings with his wives. One or more of 
              them almost invariably accompanied him on his journeys and campaigns. 
              To ensure fairness they would draw lots as to which wife or wives 
              would accompany him. 
            His 
              wives were thus not kept locked up so that they could not experience 
              what was going on in the outside world. They wore modest clothes 
              (hijab) and went out and saw everything that was going on, and they 
              participated when necessary, for example in nursing the wounded 
              on the battlefields. 
            The 
              following Hadith is narrated by Aisha (raa): 
            "Umar 
              once criticised the Prophet’s wife Saudah for going out, saying 
              he had recognised her in the street. So she appealed to the Prophet 
              (saws) for support and he supported her saying: "Women have the 
              right to go out for their needs." [Bukhari] 
            Similarly 
              the Prophet (saws) allowed his wives and other women to go out to 
              the Mosques for their prayers. He also advised other men: 
            "Do 
              not prevent the female servants of Allah (i.e Mosques)" [Muslim] 
            The 
              ideal Muslim husband therefore does not impose restrictions on his 
              wife greater then those imposed by Allah (swt), or by the Prophet 
              (saws) on his own family. 
            All 
              the foregoing indicate that the women who is married to an ideal 
              Muslim husband is protected but not suppressed, and is therefore 
              likely to be happy and contented. 
            However, 
              the Muslim husband is not expected to please his wife at all cost, 
              if what pleases her may be wrong or against her interests or the 
              interests of the family. 
            The 
              Qur’an say’s: 
            "O 
              you who have attained to faith! Ward off from yourselves and your 
              families  
              that fire (of the hereafter) whose fuel is Human beings and stones." 
              [Qur’an 
              66:6] 
            In 
              this respect a husband has a duty to ensure that his wife is fully 
              educated as a Muslim. If this has been neglected in her parents’ 
              home, he must take necessary steps to remedy it. Either by teaching 
              her himself or by arranging for her Islamic education by other means. 
              The husband is expected to give leadership in the family. We have 
              seen that this form of leadership is not dictatorship or tyranny. 
              The wise husband will, as indicated, consult his wife on important 
              matters concerning the family, and if he sees her advice is good, 
              accept it. However, Islam has given the man authority as the head 
              of the family, and he is expected to abide by the Qur’an and Sunnah 
              and endeavour to ensure that his family do not violate Islamic norms 
              of behavior. The kind of treatment required should not therefore 
              include condoning her misbehavior. 
            The 
              Qur’an has prescribed a specific graded series of three steps, which 
              the husband should take if the wife shows that she is rebelling 
              against Islamic norms of conduct. 
            His 
              first step should be to speak to her seriously about the implication 
              and likely consequences of what she is doing. If she fails to respond 
              to this sincere admonition, his next step is to suspend marital 
              relations with her for a period of time, If this also fails he is 
              permitted to beat her lightly as a final act of correction. If she 
              then complies then the husband should take no further action against 
              her. [Qur’an 4:34] 
            This 
              beating is the last resort, and not the first one, and the Prophet 
              (saws) placed some limitations on it, as follows: 
            (a) 
              It should not be on the face or on any easily injured part of the 
              body; 
            (b) 
              It should not be hard enough to cause pain or injury or leave a 
              mark. 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) indicated that if a man must beat his wife it should 
              be more or less symbolic, with something like a toothbrush. 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) himself very much disliked the beating of wives, 
              and never beat any of his own. In Abu Da’ud’s collection of Hadith 
              he is reported by Laqit B. Sabrah to have said: 
            "Admonish 
              your wife, and if there be any good in her she will receive it; 
              and beat not your wife like a slave." 
            In 
              another Hadith from Ayas b. Abdullah he specifically said:- 
            "Do 
              not beat Allah’s female servants (i.e women)" [Abu 
              Da’ud, Ibn Majah] 
            In 
              Tirmidhi’s collection is another Hadith related by Amru b. al Ahwas: 
            "And 
              enjoin on one another goodness towards women; verily they are married 
              to you: you have no power over them at all unless they come in for 
              a flagrantly filthy action; but if they are devoted to you, then 
              seek no way against them. And verily, you have rights over your 
              women, and they have rights over you." [Tirmidhi] 
            The 
              Muslim husband therefore has no right to beat his wife indiscriminately 
              or habitually for petty offences, and if he does, the wife has a 
              right to seek divorce by a Shari’ah court. Similarly, as we can 
              see, Islam has not authorised men to beat up their wives. 
            The 
              phenomenon of wife beating is not peculiar to Muslim’s- it is found 
              in all parts of the world among certain types of men. However, some 
              Muslims unjustly claim that they have religious sanction when they 
              beat their wives, while in most cases they are beating them only 
              because they themselves are brutal by nature, or just in a bad temper. 
            Bad 
              temper is to be controlled, not vented on the weaker sex. The Prophet 
              (saws) referred to this in another Hadith when he said: 
            "He 
              is not strong who throws people down, but he is strong among us 
              who controls himself when he is angry." [Bukhari 
              and Muslim] 
            Aisha 
              observed this self-control in the Prophet (saws) behavior: 
            The 
              Prophet (saws) never beat any of his wives or servants; in fact 
              he did not strike anything with his hand except in the cause of 
              Allah, or when the prohibitions of Allah were violated, and he retaliated 
              on behalf of Allah. 
            The 
              ideal Muslim husband therefore strives to emulate the Prophet’s 
              (saws) practice by avoiding beating completely and discouraging 
              it from others. It is not at all becoming for a Muslim to be a wife-beater 
              in defiance of the Prophet’s (saws) explicit dislike of the practice. 
            This 
              brings us to another interesting aspect of the Prophet’s (saws) 
              relationship with his wives. 
            He 
              apparently allowed his wives to do what is called "answering back" 
              to men who think that women, like children, should be seen and not 
              heard. There are several recorded instances of the Prophet’s (saws) 
              companions remonstrating with him or with his wives about this practice. 
              Nevertheless he chose to allow his wives to speak their minds. 
            An 
              incident related in Ibn Ishaq’s sirat Rasul Allah (An early biography 
              of the Prophet*) makes an interesting reading: 
            One 
              day Umar rebuked his wife for something and she sharply answered 
              him back: and when he expostulated with her she replied that the 
              wives of the Prophet (saws) were in the habit of answering him back 
              so why should she not do the same? "And there is one of them," she 
              added, meaning their daughter (Hafsah), "Who speaks her mind unabashed 
              from morning until night." Greatly troubled by this, Umar went to 
              Hafsah, who did not deny that what her mother said was true. "You 
              have neither the grace of Aisha nor the beauty of Zainab," he said, 
              hoping to shake her self confidence; and when these words seemed 
              to have no effect, he added: "Are you so sure that if you anger 
              the Prophet (saws), Allah will not destroy you in his anger?" Then 
              he went to his cousin Umm Salamah (another wife of the Prophet) 
              and said: "Is it true that you speak your minds to Allah’s messenger 
              (saws) and answer him with no respect?". "By all that is wonderful,"said 
              Umm Salamah, "What call have you to come between Allah’s messenger 
              (saws) and his wives? Yes, by God, we speak our minds, and if he 
              allows us to do so that is his affair, and if he forbids us he will 
              find us more obedient to him then we are to you." Umar then realised 
              he had gone too far and withdrew. 
            In 
              this anecdote we can clearly hear the voices of women who respect 
              their husband not because they are afraid of him or out of hypocrisy, 
              but out of genuine admiration and love. The fact that he allowed 
              them to speak their minds shows that the Prophet (saws) never regarded 
              women as slaves or second-class citizens but as human beings to 
              whom Allah (swt) has given reason and the ability to distinguish 
              right from wrong as he has given them to men. 
            Aisha 
              went further in a Hadith to say that when the Prophet (saws) told 
              her something she would question him closely about it so that she 
              could understand its justification before she was satisfied. The 
              Prophet (saws) did not tell her she had no right to cross question 
              him because he was a Prophet and a man, while she was only a young 
              woman. It appears on the contrary that he appreciated her critical 
              faculty and clear thinking. 
            *Retold 
              in Muhammad- his Life based on the Earliest Source by Lings 
              (Islamic Texts Society/George Allen & Unwin 1983) 
            From 
              this we can see that the Prophet (saws) had such calm inner certainty 
              and natural leadership qualities that he did not need to assert 
              himself over his wives, or be on the defensive against them. Those 
              men who behave like tyrants in the home, who assert their rule in 
              an arbitrary or violent manner, are usually the weak ones who actually 
              suffer from hidden inferiority complexes and are afraid of being 
              shown up as mentally or morally inferior to their wives. To forestall 
              this they physically frighten their wives, who are then afraid to 
              open their mouths in their husband’s presence, let alone to disagree 
              with him. 
            Another 
              incident illustrates how the Prophet (saws) asserted his leadership 
              of his family without harsh words or violence. This is revealed 
              in the way he treated his wives when they became too demanding of 
              the comforts of this world. Aisha (raa) related that before the 
              capture of the oasis of Khaybar she had not known what it was to 
              eat her fill of dates. The Prophet’s wives, fully aware of the general 
              poverty of the Muslims in Medina, asked only for their basic needs. 
              After the capture of Khaybar with it’s rich agricultural produce, 
              the Muslims were better off, and the Prophet (saws) was able to 
              give his wives some presents, and they were not slow in learning 
              to ask for more comforts. This led to problems because in fairness, 
              what was given to one should be given to all, and this could not 
              always be exactly fulfilled. There developed considerable resentment 
              among some of his wives, which disrupted the peace of the household. 
              When his advice to them was not heeded he followed the next Qur’anic 
              step and withdrew himself from them all and stayed in a roofed verandah 
              that was the only room he had apart from his wives’ apartments. 
            Rumor 
              soon spread that the Prophet (saws) had divorced his wives, and 
              the wives, in suspense, regretted bitterly their demands on him. 
              He then let it be known through Umar that he had not divorced them 
              but that he did not wish to see any of them until a full lunar month 
              had elapsed. 
            At 
              the end of the month he asked his wives one by one to make their 
              own choice in accordance with the newly revealed verses of the Qur’an: 
            "O 
              Prophet, say to your wives: If you desire but the life of this world 
              and it’s charms, then come and I will bestow it’s goods upon you, 
              I will release you with a fair release. But if you desire Allah 
              and his messenger and the abode of the hereafter, then verily Allah 
              has laid in store for you a mighty reward, for such of you as do 
              good." 
              [Qur’an 
              33:28-29] 
            Aisha 
              replied without hesitation: "Verily, I desire Allah and his Messenger 
              and the abode of the hereafter" and there was not one of his wives 
              who did not choose the same. These events are related in a number 
              of Hadith books, including Bukhari and Muslim. * 
            Here 
              we see a husband who in spite of his love and sympathy for his wives, 
              would not be carried away to commit injustice between them, not 
              put himself into difficulties or wrong -doing in order to satisfy 
              their desires beyond what was necessary. He was not ready for the 
              role of the "hen-pecked husband." His firmness in the matter quickly 
              made his wives see it in its proper perspective, and peace was restored 
              to the household without recourse to divorce or even harsh word. 
            It 
              is incidents like these that make it quite clear why the Prophet 
              (saws) is held up a beautiful example to the Muslims in every aspect 
              of his life. 
            There 
              are of course numerous other facets of his personality and behavior, 
              which contributed to making him an ideal husband. 
            He 
              was of course clean and pure both in his thoughts and person, and 
              very generous in accordance with his own saying: 
            "Verily 
              Allah is pure and loves the pure, is clean and loves the clean, 
              is beneficent and loves the beneficent, is generous and loves the 
              generous." [Tirmidhi] 
            Another 
              very important characteristic was his love of children. Love of 
              her own children is almost automatic to a mother and with that love 
              goes a care and concern for their children in any matter with the 
              same degree of love, and consider the children to be "women’s affair". 
              In our own society today this is a common phenomenon where it is 
              the mother who often plays the major role in ensuring that the children 
              are clothed and cared for, that their school fees are paid, that 
              they learn good behavior and so on. While it is good that the mother 
              shows this love and concern, it is not approved for father to abandon 
              his own moral and financial responsibilities and ignore the proper 
              education and upbringing of his own children. 
            We 
              have mentioned the Prophet’s (saws) own role in the upbringing of 
              his own daughters (it was only the daughters that survived to maturity) 
              and on his emphasis on education for both sexes. There are also 
              numerous Hadith indicating his love for children and his practice 
              of showing his love for them. 
            For 
              example in a Hadith from Abu Hurairah (raa) it is related as follows: 
            "The 
              Prophet of Allah kissed his grandson Hassan the son of Ali in the 
              presence of Agra’ B. Habis, whereupon Agra’ said: "Verily, I have 
              children and yet I have not kissed any of them." The Prophet looked 
              towards him and said: ‘ What can I do for you if Allah has taken 
              away mercy from your heart. He that shows no mercy shall have no 
              mercy shown to him." [Bukhari 
              and Muslim] 
            The 
              Muslim family is therefore ideally a very united family. Mutual 
              understanding between husband and wife lies at the root of it. The 
              Islamic upbringing of children is one of its most important functions. 
              For it to succeed as the basic unit of the Muslim Ummah, both husband 
              and wife need to know their duties and to practice self-control 
              in trying to abide by the Islamic code of conduct within the family. 
            I wish 
              to draw this paper to a close by approaching the subject briefly 
              from a different angle. We have so far looked at the duties of the 
              Muslim husband as spelled out in the Qur’an and seen how these points 
              were expanded and added to in the Sunnah. We have also taken recorded 
              incidents in the life of the Prophet (saws) as an illustration of 
              an ideal Muslim husband in action. 
            Lastly, 
              I approached the question "What is an ideal Muslim husband" by asking 
              Muslim women to tell me what they thought. 
            To 
              this end a questionnaire was passed to a random group of Muslim 
              women, who informed me what they considered the most desirable qualities 
              for an ideal Muslim husband to be. 
            To 
              this end, a random group of 35 Muslim women living locally, mainly 
              married ones were selected. 
            The 
              five most important qualities scored 2 points each and the five 
              next most important qualities scored 1 point each. The result is 
              shown below: 
            Women’s 
              Order of Priority in the Desirable Qualities of an Ideal Muslim 
              Husband 
            Points 
            1st. 
              A Pious Muslim 49 
            2nd. 
              Truthfulness and honesty 47 
            3rd 
              A good leader 40 
            4th 
              Justice and fairness 38 
            5th 
              Love of children 37 
            6th 
              Kindness and consideration 31 
            7th 
              Readiness to consult his wife 30 
            8th 
              Good manners 29 
            9th 
              Chastity and good morals 26 
            10th 
              Trustworthiness and reliability 25 
            11th 
              Avoids quarrelling and beating 22 
            12th 
              Clean habits 20 
            13th 
              Strength of mind and will 19 
            14th 
              Gentleness 17 
            15th 
              Generosity 14 
            16th 
              A loving nature 16 
            17th 
              Ability to be contented with one wife 15 
            18th 
              Sense of humour 13 
            19th 
              Reasonableness 11 
            20th 
              Firmness 9 
            21st 
              Intelligence 8 
            22nd 
              Seriousness 7 
            23rd 
              Good looks 6 
            24th 
              Physical strength 4 
            25th 
              Wealth 1 
            This 
              list of qualities is not of course comprehensive, and there are 
              a few important omissions. However, it raises many interesting points 
              for our brothers to consider in their endeavor to qualify as a potential 
              or actual ideal Muslim husband. 
            Those 
              who feared that by adhering to Islamic piety and moral standards 
              they would frighten women away will see that they are actually at 
              the top of the league. 
            This 
              information also confirms the natural order of things referred to 
              and upheld in the Qur’an, in that women do apparently want their 
              men folk to lead and not be led. Leadership has to be deserved and 
              qualified by all the other qualities mentioned in the upper part 
              of the list, such as piety, truthfulness, fairness, kindness, consultation, 
              good manners, good morals and so on. 
            It 
              is interesting to go over in one’s mind the qualities of the Prophet 
              (saws) mentioned in the earlier part of this paper and match them 
              with this list to see how far the Prophet’s (saws) behavior to his 
              wives demonstrates perfectly those qualities to which women give 
              priority. 
            Therefore 
              any man who wants to make a success of his marriage cannot go wrong 
              if he takes as his model and example the practice of the blessed 
              Prophet (saws). 
            For 
              our brothers I pray for Allah to give them the faith and moral strength 
              to attain those great qualities and thereby make a success of their 
              marriages. 
            For 
              our sisters I pray for Allah’s guidance to make each of us worthy 
              of being the ideal wife of an ideal Muslim husband. 
            By 
              B. Aisha Lemu. 
            Revised 
              and edited by Muslim Information Service 
           |